PetDogTrainingToday is supported by readers. When you purchase through links on this site, we may earn a small commission. Learn more.

Top 5 Dog Training Myths Debunked: What Really Works

Training your dog should be a fun and rewarding experience, but it can get a little frustrating when you’re dealing with outdated advice that just doesn’t work. Let’s be honest—dog training has come a long way, and some of the old-school methods are about as useful as a chew toy made of marshmallows. So, let’s bust some of the biggest dog training myths out there and give you the scoop on what actually works.

Plus, we’ve got some awesome course recommendations from SpiritDog Training to help you and your pup get on the right track!

5 Dog Training Myths Debunked

Let’s dive into some of the most common misconceptions about dog training and set the record straight!

Myth 1: Dogs Want to Dominate You

boxer type dog in the driving seat of a car

You’ve probably heard that your dog is secretly plotting to take over your house and become the alpha. Sounds intense, right? This whole idea comes from some pretty outdated studies on wolves, and somehow it stuck around in dog training circles like an annoying piece of dog hair on your favorite sweater.

The Reality: Guess what? Your dog isn’t out to dethrone you. Those old wolf studies were based on captive wolves in a weird zoo setting, and they’ve been debunked. Your dog just wants to be your buddy, not your boss. The key to a well-behaved dog isn’t about showing them who’s boss; it’s about understanding their behavior and using positive reinforcement.

What Works: Instead of getting all alpha on your pup, focus on building a relationship based on trust and respect. Use treats, praise, and play to reward good behavior. Your dog will love you for it—and behave better, too!

Course Recommendation: Check out the Perfect Dog Obedience Bundle from SpiritDog Training. It’s packed with tips on how to train your dog the positive way.


Myth 2: Treats Are Bribes

beagle dog with someone dangling a biscuit in front of them

Some folks think that using treats in training is like bribing your dog. They believe your dog should do what you say because they respect you—not because they’re getting something out of it.

The Reality: Newsflash: Dogs aren’t thinking about respect when they sit for a treat—they’re just happy to do something that gets them a reward. Treats are a super effective way to teach your dog new tricks and behaviors. And no, it’s not bribery; it’s positive reinforcement, and it works.

What Works: Start by rewarding your dog with treats for every good behavior. As they get better, you can start giving treats less often, but keep the praise and love coming. Eventually, your dog will do what you want just because they know it’s the right thing to do—and because they love making you happy.

Course Recommendation: If you’re new to this or just got a puppy, the Ultimate Puppy Program Bundle is your go-to course. It’s perfect for getting those good habits in place early on.


Myth 3: You Can’t Teach an Old Dog New Tricks

old dog a bit grey around the muzzle lazing on a sofa

There’s an old saying that you can’t teach an old dog new tricks. A lot of people think that once their dog is past the puppy stage, they’re set in their ways, and training is a lost cause.

The Reality: Total nonsense! Dogs of all ages can learn new things. Sure, older dogs might take a little more time to catch on, but they’re definitely capable of learning. It’s never too late to teach your dog something new.

What Works: Make training a part of your daily routine, whether it’s during walks, playtime, or just hanging out at home. Start with simple commands, and as your dog gets the hang of it, you can introduce more complex tricks. Keep it fun, and don’t forget the treats!

Course Recommendation: Want to keep your dog sharp no matter their age? The Perfect Focus Bundle will help you keep your dog’s attention and obedience on point.


Myth 4: You Have to Be the Bad Guy Sometimes

someone pointing their finger in an aggressive manner to a small black and tan chihuahua

Some people believe that to train a dog, you have to be strict or even a bit mean. The idea is that punishment is necessary to get your dog to behave.

The Reality: Actually, punishment can do more harm than good. It can make your dog scared, anxious, or even aggressive. Positive reinforcement—rewarding your dog for good behavior— is much more effective and helps build a stronger bond between you and your pup.

What Works: Instead of getting tough, focus on rewarding the good stuff and ignoring or redirecting the bad. Positive reinforcement helps your dog understand what you want without stress or fear. Be consistent, patient, and stay positive, and you’ll see results.

Course Recommendation: If you’re dealing with a reactive dog, the Tackling Reactivity Online Bundle is a lifesaver. It’s all about managing and reducing reactivity with positive methods.


Myth 5: There’s Only One Way to Train a Dog

daschund walking on a lead looking up at its owner

Some folks think there’s a one-size-fits-all approach to dog training. If one method doesn’t work, they feel like they’ve failed.

The Reality: Dogs are just as unique as people. What works for one dog might not work for another, and that’s totally okay! Training should be flexible and tailored to fit your dog’s breed, personality, and experiences.

What Works: Pay attention to how your dog responds to different methods, and don’t be afraid to mix things up. If you’re stuck, consider getting help from a pro who can offer personalized advice. And remember, it’s all about what works best for you and your dog.

Course Recommendation: The Training Confidence Booster is perfect for building your confidence as a trainer and helping you find the best approach for your unique dog.


5 Dog Training Myths Debunked: Conclusion

Dog training doesn’t have to be complicated or stressful. By ditching these outdated myths and embracing positive, science-based methods, you can build a stronger, happier relationship with your dog. Remember, training is a journey you and your pup take together—so have fun with it!

And if you need some extra guidance, SpiritDog Training has got you covered with a range of courses that’ll make you and your dog the best training team ever.


Latest Dog Training and Behavior Articles